I know what I'm going to say will be embarrassing to most of my musician friends who will think I'm just an unsophisticated non-musician but you should by now know that I don't care for public opinion. I was just looking through some clarinet pieces for my own personal entertainment and I came across some modern pieces.
I sometimes find modern music (just like modern art) quite a letdown. The music can be downright horrid and even cacophonous. Do people really appreciate such music or are they just being pretentious as many people do when they want to appear cultivated and refined?
Here's an excerpt from a modern piece of music composed no more than 50 years ago:
Let's examine this bit and let's be rational. Do you really enjoy this music? I honestly don't and here's my reason.
Do you see in the first line the glis from D-natural to Db? Call me unsophisticated if you like but that's awful. When I first heard it without looking at the score, I really thought the musician hit the wrong note and tried to glis to the right note. It was incredibly revolting. What excuse can a composer have for writing that? He probably just wanted to stand out and be different but writing awful music is not the way to stand out.
Next, do you see the "scrawling" over the third and fourth notes (the two Ds just above middle-C) in the second line? Non-clarinet players may not know what that means but it's really nothing more than a direct instruction from the composer to play those notes so that they grate on the ear. Can you imagine that? When a clarinettist sees that notation, he is required to play the note as if he is throwing up what he's eaten into the clarinet.
I've only picked two examples out of the many ways modern composers have to ruin music for their listeners. All the great composers of different nationalities who composed beautiful music for the clarinet including Beethoven, Mozart, Schumann, Mendelssohn, Spohr, Crusell, Weber and even modern composers such as Poulenc, Saint-Saëns and Lutoslawski do not ruin the music with such horrid devices.
Perhaps I'm just lacking in that musical sophistication that people with a finer ear can appreciate and I can't. But I don't think so. My guess is modern composers try too hard to be different. There are only so many musical variations that one can have and after a while they really feel they ought to do something radically different. True, it may be outrageously and shockingly different and it may even require a great deal of virtuosic skill for a performer to get some of these notes right but musicians are not circus clowns performing tricks that are hard to accomplish but that are of negative musical value.
Anyway, this is just my rant after having gone through a stack of music scores on a Friday evening and you don't have to agree with me. The sound of fingernails scratching a blackboard has the effect of making me feel weak with revulsion but if you enjoy that kind of sound, go ahead and listen to it. You might want to comment below why you like the sound of fingernails scratching the blackboard.
Showing posts with label Music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Music. Show all posts
Friday, August 29, 2014
Wednesday, January 22, 2014
Yet Another Boo-boo by the Straits Times
Remember how embarrassing it was for the Straits Times when it reported that Kim Jong Un fed his uncle live to 200 wild dogs? If you are interested in what the BBC had to say about the Straits Times with regard to that reporting, please click here.
I just saw in today's Straits Times on page C5 of Life an obituary of Claudio Abbado. The music world has been in deep mourning since his death on 20 January, just two days ago. The Straits Times published today a tribute to him but guess what? They got the wrong photograph of him. Or rather, they got a photograph of another musician.
Here's a photo I've just taken from the Straits Times:
When I first saw the photo, I almost fell off my chair. How could the editors of the Straits Times be so wrong? Isn't that a pic of the famous Italian pianist Pollini? What? Has Pollini died too?
I then did a search on google and no, Pollini is alive and well and thank God for that. It was the Straits Times that made an unpardonable mistake. And I think I know the reason for Straits Times' blunder. Whoever did the reporting or the editing of this obituary obviously didn't know Abbado from Adam. Any musician in black tie is immediately taken for Abbado. I wanted to trace the source of the photo that the Straits Times got wrong and I did a google image search for "Pollini and Abbado" and I think I have the answer. The Straits Times probably took the photo that was published in AFP and other major international newspapers which spoke about Abbado's passing two days ago. For example, see this article published in Khaleej Times on 20 January 2014 which contains this photo:
This is my guess of what happened. That's obviously the photo that Straits Times made use of. In that photo, Pollini was standing next to Abbado and the Straits Times editor wanted to trim it to fit the space in his column but he had no notion what Abbado looked like and had a 50% chance of getting it right but alas, luck was not on his side and he got it wrong. How anybody can fail to see that that was not the image of Abbado is something I can't understand. Surely someone in the Straits Times must know at least what Abbado looked like? Isn't the Life section of the Straits Times dedicated to the arts and music? I cannot believe anyone with the smallest love for music can possibly not know what Claudio Abbado looked like.
Well, that's the Straits Times for you. I have a lot to say about the Straits Times and English grammar but I'll save that for another day. Right now, as the whole world mourns the passing of the great Claudio Abbado, I'm annoyed that the Straits Times can't even get the picture of such a legendary conductor right. Why then did it bother to publish an obituary in the first place?
I just saw in today's Straits Times on page C5 of Life an obituary of Claudio Abbado. The music world has been in deep mourning since his death on 20 January, just two days ago. The Straits Times published today a tribute to him but guess what? They got the wrong photograph of him. Or rather, they got a photograph of another musician.
Here's a photo I've just taken from the Straits Times:
When I first saw the photo, I almost fell off my chair. How could the editors of the Straits Times be so wrong? Isn't that a pic of the famous Italian pianist Pollini? What? Has Pollini died too?
I then did a search on google and no, Pollini is alive and well and thank God for that. It was the Straits Times that made an unpardonable mistake. And I think I know the reason for Straits Times' blunder. Whoever did the reporting or the editing of this obituary obviously didn't know Abbado from Adam. Any musician in black tie is immediately taken for Abbado. I wanted to trace the source of the photo that the Straits Times got wrong and I did a google image search for "Pollini and Abbado" and I think I have the answer. The Straits Times probably took the photo that was published in AFP and other major international newspapers which spoke about Abbado's passing two days ago. For example, see this article published in Khaleej Times on 20 January 2014 which contains this photo:
This is my guess of what happened. That's obviously the photo that Straits Times made use of. In that photo, Pollini was standing next to Abbado and the Straits Times editor wanted to trim it to fit the space in his column but he had no notion what Abbado looked like and had a 50% chance of getting it right but alas, luck was not on his side and he got it wrong. How anybody can fail to see that that was not the image of Abbado is something I can't understand. Surely someone in the Straits Times must know at least what Abbado looked like? Isn't the Life section of the Straits Times dedicated to the arts and music? I cannot believe anyone with the smallest love for music can possibly not know what Claudio Abbado looked like.
Well, that's the Straits Times for you. I have a lot to say about the Straits Times and English grammar but I'll save that for another day. Right now, as the whole world mourns the passing of the great Claudio Abbado, I'm annoyed that the Straits Times can't even get the picture of such a legendary conductor right. Why then did it bother to publish an obituary in the first place?
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
May God bless our new Bishop
The new bishop who will be consecrated this week is someone my wife and I are fond of. It was he who solemnised our matrimony and it was he who blessed our first home. I will be playing with the church orchestra at his consecration service and I managed to rope my kids in. Early this morning, my kids and I ran through the pieces. My poor wife can only play the piano and pianists are always sidelined. Only one person is needed to play the organ / piano.
May God bless our new bishop.
May God bless our new bishop.
Sunday, November 11, 2012
Why I love this island so!
Religious violence is something you see every day on the news. If it's not Nigerian churches being torched by the Islamist terrorist group Boko Haram, it's probably the tension between Hindu militants and Muslim extremists in India.
All the violence we read about is absolutely foreign to us who live in Singapore. Whatever Western critics may say about a "totalitarian" government (which isn't true at all) or the lack of freedom (I don't know about you but I can do without the freedom to get killed or maimed), my advice to the critics is this - you remain in YOUR country and I'll live here. On the other hand, if you happen to live here and you really don't like it at all, it's a free world and you can always go where you think the grass is greener. Lately, there have been a lot of foreigners who come to Singapore and avail themselves of the goodness of the land but post offensive and abusive remarks against the country they're milking from. Here is where Singapore should show its "totalitarian" strength and send these ungrateful chaps packing.
Anyway, this morning, after a very early breakfast in Little India, I cycled round this lovely part of Singapore and took pics of the various places of worship. I had intended for this post to be a wordless post with pics alone to tell the tale but alas, it's hard to remain silent when what I see through my camera lens is nothing but perfect peace and beauty. Mind you, these places of worship are of the four major different world faiths and here they stand, no more than 100 metres from one another in perfect harmony, wonderfully tolerant and a great picture of what faith truly means as they each proclaim its gospel of peace and goodwill to all men.
It's when I see such peace and harmony of these four great faiths in close proximity to one another that I know in my heart of hearts that God is in his heaven and all's right with the world. May God bless Singapore and its far-sighted leaders! OK, I'll be silent from here on. Enjoy the pics!
As I was busy snapping a pic of the Hindu temple, a bell suddenly broke the silence of the morning and religious music could be heard within the temple. I took a quick video of the worship session from the road. The video is a little shaky; I had to balance my bicycle against my body, remove my gloves and hold them with my teeth and use both hands to take the video. If you watch the video carefully, you will see a guy in a pink shirt, slightly to the right playing a wind instrument but he stands in the shade so it's very hard to make out the instrument he's playing. It closely resembles the clarinet but it's much larger and the bell is way too large for a clarinet. But it's definitely a reed instrument because I saw the reed - placed on the mouthpiece just as in a clarinet. It's the only wind instrument that you can hear in the video. I really wonder what instrument it is.
All the violence we read about is absolutely foreign to us who live in Singapore. Whatever Western critics may say about a "totalitarian" government (which isn't true at all) or the lack of freedom (I don't know about you but I can do without the freedom to get killed or maimed), my advice to the critics is this - you remain in YOUR country and I'll live here. On the other hand, if you happen to live here and you really don't like it at all, it's a free world and you can always go where you think the grass is greener. Lately, there have been a lot of foreigners who come to Singapore and avail themselves of the goodness of the land but post offensive and abusive remarks against the country they're milking from. Here is where Singapore should show its "totalitarian" strength and send these ungrateful chaps packing.
Anyway, this morning, after a very early breakfast in Little India, I cycled round this lovely part of Singapore and took pics of the various places of worship. I had intended for this post to be a wordless post with pics alone to tell the tale but alas, it's hard to remain silent when what I see through my camera lens is nothing but perfect peace and beauty. Mind you, these places of worship are of the four major different world faiths and here they stand, no more than 100 metres from one another in perfect harmony, wonderfully tolerant and a great picture of what faith truly means as they each proclaim its gospel of peace and goodwill to all men.
It's when I see such peace and harmony of these four great faiths in close proximity to one another that I know in my heart of hearts that God is in his heaven and all's right with the world. May God bless Singapore and its far-sighted leaders! OK, I'll be silent from here on. Enjoy the pics!
As I was busy snapping a pic of the Hindu temple, a bell suddenly broke the silence of the morning and religious music could be heard within the temple. I took a quick video of the worship session from the road. The video is a little shaky; I had to balance my bicycle against my body, remove my gloves and hold them with my teeth and use both hands to take the video. If you watch the video carefully, you will see a guy in a pink shirt, slightly to the right playing a wind instrument but he stands in the shade so it's very hard to make out the instrument he's playing. It closely resembles the clarinet but it's much larger and the bell is way too large for a clarinet. But it's definitely a reed instrument because I saw the reed - placed on the mouthpiece just as in a clarinet. It's the only wind instrument that you can hear in the video. I really wonder what instrument it is.
Saturday, April 21, 2012
For the sake of publicity
Of all the students in uni (I have to remind myself not to write "varsity" which is dated and for old people only), music students must be the most unusual. They evoke a strange set of mixed feelings in me - awe and sympathy. What they have in them is something none of us mere mortals can ever dream of. It's funny how they can create so much magic by just running their fingers down the keys of the clarinet or oboe or sawing the strings of their instrument with the bow. Those of us who play musical instruments know just how incredibly difficult it is to achieve that kind of virtuosity. And yet, there's no money in what they do!
The idea of the impoverished artist has been so romanticized that we sometimes forget how bleak and unromantic it is to be truly impoverished. Many orchestras in Europe have done so badly that they have to shut down and where does that leave the musicians?
Female musicians may very well fare much better. They can always fall back on their feminine charms and a lovely seaside album cover of a female violinist standing knee-deep in the sea dressed in some skimpy dress soaked in seawater is sure to attract the attention of men who aren't really interested in Paganini's Capriccios. Vanessa Mae may be an inspiration to other female musicians to flaunt their bodies and remind their male admirers who can't tell a crotchet from a quaver that you don't have to be fat and dumpy to be a brilliant musician but what about male musicians?
I was quite amused when I first saw this flyer advertising a recital by a young student violinist in Taiwan.
I seem to recall an older photograph in which all four of them posed naked in different parts of a bathroom with their instruments strategically shielding their nether regions. I remember that photograph only because it occurred to me at the time that they wouldn't have dared to pose that way if they played the clarinet, the oboe or the flute!
Do other artists resort to using suggestive photos of themselves? Can you imagine Salman Rushdie standing starkers holding a copy of Midnight's Children in front of him? I can't but of course I'm being silly. Rushdie's selling point is his art of story telling, not his body.
But shouldn't it be the same for all artists? The selling point for any artist has got to be his art and not how he looks with or without clothes. That may be the ideal but as we all know, we don't live in an ideal world and very few in Asia or even elsewhere in the world really listen to good music. Women have always worn revealing clothes to get some attention and why should a young male artist not make full use of his nicely sculptured torso? It's not his fault that the world is teeming with uncouth plebeians who would rather go to a Linkin Park concert than spend the evening listening to Stravinsky.
The idea of the impoverished artist has been so romanticized that we sometimes forget how bleak and unromantic it is to be truly impoverished. Many orchestras in Europe have done so badly that they have to shut down and where does that leave the musicians?
Female musicians may very well fare much better. They can always fall back on their feminine charms and a lovely seaside album cover of a female violinist standing knee-deep in the sea dressed in some skimpy dress soaked in seawater is sure to attract the attention of men who aren't really interested in Paganini's Capriccios. Vanessa Mae may be an inspiration to other female musicians to flaunt their bodies and remind their male admirers who can't tell a crotchet from a quaver that you don't have to be fat and dumpy to be a brilliant musician but what about male musicians?
I was quite amused when I first saw this flyer advertising a recital by a young student violinist in Taiwan.
You may not be able to see clearly at the bottom left of the photo what pieces he was to play around this time last year but no, Lady Gaga's hit songs weren't in his repertoire. The programme for the evening was not Hotbod gyrating to the beat of Donna Summer's "Hot Stuff" from that famous 1997 movie "The Full Monty" (sorry, am I dated again?) but he would be playing Stravisnsky's Italian Suite and two violin sonatas by Eugene Ysaÿe and Grieg wrapped, I'm sure, in several layers of impenetrable fabric right up to his neck.
In Singapore, the T'ang Quartet are no strangers to posing for the camera in their birthday suits. The picture below is from their ad in the 2007 Singapore Arts Festival.
I seem to recall an older photograph in which all four of them posed naked in different parts of a bathroom with their instruments strategically shielding their nether regions. I remember that photograph only because it occurred to me at the time that they wouldn't have dared to pose that way if they played the clarinet, the oboe or the flute!
Do other artists resort to using suggestive photos of themselves? Can you imagine Salman Rushdie standing starkers holding a copy of Midnight's Children in front of him? I can't but of course I'm being silly. Rushdie's selling point is his art of story telling, not his body.
But shouldn't it be the same for all artists? The selling point for any artist has got to be his art and not how he looks with or without clothes. That may be the ideal but as we all know, we don't live in an ideal world and very few in Asia or even elsewhere in the world really listen to good music. Women have always worn revealing clothes to get some attention and why should a young male artist not make full use of his nicely sculptured torso? It's not his fault that the world is teeming with uncouth plebeians who would rather go to a Linkin Park concert than spend the evening listening to Stravinsky.
Sunday, April 15, 2012
Monday, February 7, 2011
Say NO to mediocrity
I bought this yesterday and I'm determined to do the etudes and practices daily and kiss mediocrity goodbye. I am a lazy man and playing scales and arpeggios is something I find quite impossible to do. But the key to good performance lies in consistent hard work. I used to work on Baermann and Otto Langey but I'm getting tired of them. A change of scene is what I need. And although they say you shouldn't judge a book by its cover, I think this cover is pretty good. It encourages me to pick up my clarinet. At least for now.MUSIC EXAMS TRAUMATIC FOR CHILDREN
MUSIC EXAMS ARE PSYCHOLOGICALLY TRAUMATIC FOR CHILDREN
PART 1
Have you ever wondered what goes on in the mind of a solo performer at the start of a concert as he is bowing to the rapturous applause of the audience? As the applause dies down, he looks to the conductor and nods his readiness. The conductor turns to the orchestra and the music begins.
I have never had the honour of playing a concerto accompanied by a whole orchestra before a live audience but I can very well imagine what hell the performer goes through at the start of each performance. I have been through, however, something on a much more modest scale but which was no less harrowing an experience but I will come to that in a minute.
Just the other day, I was listening to this on youtube (click on it and enjoy!):
It is of course a most delightful performance of Mendelssohn’s Fingal Cave Overture but as I approached 7:36 on the video, I was seized by a strange palpitation, my breath became shorter and more rapid, the palms of my hands turned clammy and I found myself perspiring. That’s because I used to take the ABRSM and Trinity College examinations a long time ago and in one of my technical tests, I had to play an orchestral extract of that same piece.
These orchestral extracts are different from the usual three period pieces that a student has to play. They are meant to examine the student’s technical ability, especially when he’s playing in an orchestra. I recall there were two orchestral extracts I had to play for the technical test in that examination – one was this piece by Mendelssohn and the other was a Wagner’s extract. The Wagner’s piece was extremely fast and I recall slowing it down because I didn’t want to stumble and make mistakes.
Here is what the examiner wrote about my performance of the orchestral extracts. We’ll ignore the comment on my performance of Wagner in which I admit my tempo was way too slow but let’s look at the comment on my Mendelssohn:
“There was a clear line if the tone lacked projection. This was however at about half the original tempo.”
That’s music exam for you – there is always something wrong or not quite right with your performance. But I suppose the examiner must be right. He’s a renowned wind player in a well-known orchestra in the UK and he’s got impressive credentials that filled a whole page in fine print.
I don’t know if it’s just me but do you notice that praises in music exam results always end with a “But…” or a “However,…”?
I will give an example of that same exam I took. In one of my three period pieces (it’s always 3 period pieces in all graded exams), the comments begin in a rather promising vein. This was Wiedemann’s Romance which has some rather technical parts in the piece and is played unaccompanied.
“The tempo was well judged and the pulse was well maintained.” Wow! Finally, I was exonerated – my tempo which was judged to be at half the original was now declared to be “well judged”. But of course that’s not all. The judgment goes on: “ALTHOUGH there was a tendency, now unaccompanied, to tap the foot”. The examiner now comments on my foot!!!
I have a lot more to say but I will post Part 2 another day. For now, I hope that all of us will look at professional concert musicians with a great deal more respect. This is particularly important in the less “cultured” countries like mine where 99% of the population can’t play an orchestral instrument to save their lives. The next time you see a performer on the stage in a concert hall with his or her instrument, applaud a little louder because if any one of us music flops (and I have already excluded the 99% non-musicians) were to stand in his shoes with our instrument, we’d be seized by a strange palpitation, our breaths would become shorter and more rapid, the palms of our hands clammy and we’d be perspiring most pitifully.
Monday, July 19, 2010
7th Sunday after Trinity
It was a dark and dreary afternoon and the rain came down fast and furious. Enough of cliches! Naturally, I was reluctant to go to church. But I did so and I was early too! I've got to be early if I managed to park in the VIP car park. Peter gave a demonstration of his iPad and it was really impressive. He and Sarah read their part from the music score in his iPad but since my score was different, I had to stick to hard cold paper made from timbre hewn in the dwindling rainforests!
Sunday, July 4, 2010
5th Sunday after Trinity
Sorry I had to leave immediately after Communion to pick my wife up from the airport. This pic was taken by my daughter before the service began.
Monday, June 28, 2010
2010 Australian International Music Festival
Here's wishing the boys luck as they perform this afternoon at the 2010 Australian International Music Festival at the Sydney Opera House.
Friday, June 4, 2010
So, I really am participating in the Czech Clarinet Festival!
I finally emailed last night my application to participate in the clarinet festival in a music conservatory in the Czech Republic.
Under "Musical studies: (Conservatory, University, etc)", I wrote "Not applicable". My silly wife asked me to write ABRSM Graded exams and Trinity College Certificate just so they could have a good laugh at the other end.
I had to give a list of my repertoire (there was space for 4 pieces) which I'll have to perform and this is what I wrote:
1. Schumann's Fantastiestucke (1st movement)
2. Heinrich Baermann's Clarinet Septet (Adagio)
3. Lutoslawski's Dance Preludes (No. 2)
4. Donizetti's Concertino in B-flat (1st movement)
I was smart not to be overly ambitious but I still have to practise the pieces! Of course I'm going to be a disgrace at the conservatory but I don't want to be a total disgrace!
Monday, May 24, 2010
The next day (after Aldersgate Service)
I asked myself whether there'd be enough musicians for the evening service since we played at Aldersgate last night. As it turned out, 6 (including me) who played at Aldersgate Service turned up this evening: Indra, Yolyn, Peter, Joyce Tang and Yeow Chong. Additionally, Janice and Sarah were in church too. It was quite a good turn-out and I'm glad I didn't just assume nobody would be there.
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Reeds
Just bought a box of reeds. These should be enough to see me through PLMC on Saturday and St Andrew's in August, and possibly (although pretty unlikely) Christmas this year. Someone should invent an everlasting reed!
Sunday, May 16, 2010
A family that plays together
Which is the greatest? Faith, hope or love? Many religious people today insist that faith is everything. But that's not what St Paul says. To him, love is the greatest. There is no greater love than the love within a family.
Today is the first Saturday when the kids' exams are all over. We took a walk in a nearby shopping mall. Everything was fine; young children were at play at the playground and God was in his heaven and all was right with the world:
.
We had dinner and I had my lovely soft-shelled crab
When we got home, my son downloaded scores for free from the internet. That's how cheap our entertainment is - everything is for free!
The first was Beethoven's Trio for clarinet, cello and piano
But the poor pianist got a raw deal. The piano part was the hardest and my daughter who was playing the piano got my wife to take over. We played on until my wife found it too hard to sight-read. She complained that the score was too small and because this was a freebie, all parts were grouped together and the print was really small. We tried photocopying and enlarging the print but the whole thing couldn't fit in. That's what you get when you're too much of a cheapskate to buy original scores from sheetmusicplus.com
My son gave us yet a different score - he seemed to have an inexhaustible supply of free scores! This was Anton Alexander's piece for clarinet, flute, violin and cello. None of us played the flute. So, only the three parts were played and my wife was the audience.
After we were sick of that piece, my kids and I played Bach's songs which my son who appeared to have a lot of time on his hands had transcribed for our different instruments. We played other pieces of music too - the theme for Schindler's List, etc. I'm the musical idiot in the family and my kids have to write out the score for me before I can even play a single bar! Over the years, they have written quite a lot for me!
There is nothing more cosy than for the family to play music together. Most fathers in Singapore today are too proud and aloof to play music with their kids and this has resulted in a horrible rift and a breakdown of communication between parents and children. One can always start with something simple. One doesn't have to begin with Beethoven's Trio which we did because it was freely available on the net and well, we all got tied up in knots but we had a good laugh over it with wifey going "Aiyoh" all the time as she encountered impossibly tough bits. One doesn't have to be musically gifted in order to enjoy playing music. Pride is always the culprit here.
It's amazing that in today's world, one can have so much fun and laughter at absolutely no cost. And it's all in the family too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













